Sukkot FAQ

In the interest of helping Adat Shalomers further their enjoyment of Sukkot at Sukkot potlucks and throughout the Hag, the Religious Practices Committee presents the following (fictional) Frequently Asked Questions (and answers):

Dear Inquirer:

Thank you for your questions. Surely you don't expect to get any answers from Adat Shalom's Religious Practices Committee that claim to tell people what they must do to "do it right" in their sukkah!!

Just in case it might be of interest, though, here are answers to your questions from one part or another of Jewish tradition (which as you know gets a vote "not a veto" in orthodox Reconstructionism).

1. Do we make Kiddush every night?

If you have some wine, why not? Sukkot is Zeman Simchatenu, the season of our rejoicing!

2. What Kiddush?

There is a fine one on pp. 626-627 of Kol Haneshama for evening kiddushes. For an in-sukkah lunch, or if you only have time (or patience) for a two-line version, you will find it on pp. 464-465.

3. Should we make a Motzi?

Absolutely! One hasn't fulfilled the mitzvah of "dwelling" in a sukkah until one has eaten there a piece of bread at least the size of an olive (or some other combination of food considered to constitute a meal, with its appropriate blessing). Blessing: the usual ... hamotzi lechem min ha-aretz.

4. Which nights do we need a challah?

See the preceding question. The bread doesn't have to be challah, but what could be better?

5. Which nights should we light candles?

On Erev Sukkot (the first night, 4 October in 1998). On the second night if you want to follow conservative/orthodox practice here in the Diaspora. On 9 October 1998 (for shabbat!). And one or two more times more for Shemini Atzeret and Simchat Torah (but they are not really part of Sukkot). Blessings for the Yom Tov candles are on pp. 530-531 of Kol Haneshama. Blessings for Shabbat candles are on pp. 4-5.

6. In what order do we do these things and say these blessings?

  1. Light candles—on appropriate night(s)—with appropriate blessings. On the first night of Sukkot, follow this up with Shehecheyanu (on the same pages as the Yom Tov candle blessings).
  2. Say kiddush (see above for pages), drink wine.
  3. Say motzi, eat bread.
  4. Say the blessing for performing the mitzvah of dwelling in the sukkah: the usual ... asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu l'yeshev (pronounced LAY-SHEV) basukkah. If this is your first time in the sukkah this year (and you have not already done so under item 1.), this is a good time to say Shehecheyanu. And somewhere in there, shake, shake, shake your lulav – see final FAQ.

7. What is the tradition of welcoming "distinguished guests" ? If we follow it, what "guest" do we welcome on which night?

Traditionally, distinguished guests (Ushpizin) are welcomed to the sukkah. Abraham is welcomed on night 1, Isaac on night 2, Jacob on night 3, Joseph on night 4, Moses on night 5, Aaron on night 6, and David on night 7. You can probably get a neat old-fashioned poster, with authentic pictures of these guys and the traditional greeting, at either of the Jewish bookstores in Wheaton. You can also get your lulav/etrog set there. (See the last item below.)

8. What female distinguished guests could we pair up with those fellows?

Obviously, we are making this tradition up as we go along. One community has chosen Miriam, Leah, Hannah, Rebecca, Sarah, Tamar, and Rachel, the order supposedly reflecting their respective Kabbalistic significance. Another community invites Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, Leah, Miriam, Abigail, and Esther, roughly in harmony with the men. Last year, the President invited Bathsheva every night, but this year he got caught.

9. Is there a Reconstructionist version of the "welcoming the guests" routine or could we develop one?

No. Yes.

10. What else can potential hosts worry about and how should we worry?

We are supposed to enjoy ourselves in the sukkah. Therefore, If it rains hard enough in the sukkah to spoil food, or if it is cold enough in the sukkah that food congeals, one is exempt from eating there. "One who is exempt from remaining in the sukkah and does not leave is called an ignoramus, will obtain no reward for staying there, and is not permitted to say the benediction," says the Shulchan Aruch. So there.

Next year, try asking about how to know if a sukkah is really kosher, when to build it, and what to put in it.

We can also talk then about the Arbaah Minim and Jewish Indian giving.

11. Why haven't you talked more about the lulav and etrog?

The lulav and etrog are not covered in depth this year because they are used mostly in the synagogue. Nonetheless, it adds a nice touch – and it's considered a mitzvah – to bench lulav (meaning wave it with the blessing, not dead-lift from a prone position) in your own sukkah. If you have them, you may want to show and explain them to guests and say the appropriate blessing. Resist the temptation to touch or smell them improperly.

--- Your friends from the Religious Practices Committee, September 25, 1998